Skip to content
Back to the home page
Cover of The Jurisprudence of the Husayni Rites

Book

The Jurisprudence of the Husayni Rites

And the Jurists' Foundations and Their Proofs

Sayed Mahmoud Al-Mosawi

  • 446 pages
1,996 views205 downloadsFor the press

About the book

Translated from Arabic — the Arabic original is the authoritative text.Read the Arabic original

  • Title: The Jurisprudence of the Husayni Rites and the Jurists' Foundations and Their Proofs.

  • Author: Sayed Mahmoud Al-Mosawi.

  • Publisher: Dar al-Mahajja al-Baydaʾ, Beirut, Lebanon

  • First edition: 1447 AH

  • Size: Waziri – 446 pages.

From the book's introduction:

The views we present in this book will center on the views of the jurists. Even though they differ greatly among themselves, the difference remains within the context of ijtihad and its scholarly criteria; so dealing with that legitimate difference must be within legitimate ethics.


It is no secret to the reader that the jurisprudential aspect of the Husayni rites has been addressed by the jurists in various chapters among the customary chapters of fiqh, or within individual issues; the Husayni rites have not had a special chapter and book in fiqh. Therefore, it required effort on our part to gather the scattered parts of the research and organize it in the form this book has taken, in the hope that the treatment of the Husayni rites in their jurisprudential aspect will develop to encompass the rulings of detailed subsidiary issues, as is the way of Islamic jurisprudence in its continuous development.


We will review the foundations of the jurists and their proofs in the course of discussing the particular elements and headings of each rite, and we will also refer to them in summary in the first chapter when discussing the rule of the Husayni rites.


As for what is meant by the proofs of the jurists, it is the basis and the source on which the jurist relied to establish the ruling on a rite, such as the Holy Qurʾan, the noble Sunna of the Prophet (s) and his infallible Household (a), their conduct, reason and consensus, and everything that can fall within the legal proofs, in establishing the ruling or its corroborating evidence.


As for the foundations, they are the nature of the view taken of a legal proof, the extent of its validity for inference, and the extent of its relevance in inference in terms of the degree and scope of its signification. To put it another way: the foundations are the convictions the jurist has reached through scholarly research concerning the general bases of legislation on which the construction of a legal ruling rests; then comes the stage of presenting the proof and its signification.


The noble reader will find that the source of the difference sometimes lies in the nature of the understanding of the proof—such as digging into its significations or interrogating its contexts—and at other times arises from the nature of the scholarly foundation that the jurist adopts. Likewise, the nature of one's reading of reality can affect the ruling, insofar as it falls under negative impediments and prohibitive concerns, or under positive effects and gains.


In presenting this modest effort, I hope thereby to reach a mature jurisprudential knowledge on the subject of the Husayni rites, and an understanding of the jurists' differences and their agreement. In presenting them I do not claim to cover them all; rather, I have confined myself to presenting those that are well known, or that I came across, and those I saw as suitable for presentation as an example of a type of inference—since what matters most is understanding the general lines of ijtihad on the subject of the Husayni rites, not surveying the views of all the jurists in every age.


I ask Allah, the Exalted, to grant us success in serving Imam al-Husayn (a) and serving his blessed rites; and from Allah (Almighty) we seek help and aspire to rectitude.


Sayed Mahmoud Al-Mosawi

Bani Jamra / Bahrain

1441 AH

Revised and expanded in 1446 AH

Contents of the book

Table of contents

15 chapters · 181 headings
  1. 1Introductionp. 7
  2. 2Prologuep. 11
  3. 3Chapter One: The Husayni Rites: Concept and Criteriap. 17
  4. Prefacep. 17
  5. The History of Deliberations on the Husayni Ritesp. 19
  6. The Stage of al-Fadil al-Darbandi and al-ʿAllama al-Nurip. 21
  7. The Stage of the Books (al-Tanzih) and (Sawlat al-Haqq)p. 24
  8. The Concept of the Husayni Ritesp. 30
  9. On the Meaning of the Rites: Perceptible in the Lexical Sensep. 30
  10. The Rites in the Holy Qurʾanp. 33
  11. A Discussion of the Qurʾanic Significationp. 35
  12. The Husayni Rites Are among the Rites of Allahp. 36
  13. The Verse: “And whoever venerates the sacraments of Allah”p. 40
  14. The Rule of the Husayni Ritesp. 44
  15. The Husayni Rites Are the Rites of Allahp. 48
  16. The Distinctiveness of the Husayni Ritesp. 49
  17. The Objectives of the Ritesp. 53
  18. Intention and the Devotional Character of the Husayni Ritesp. 58
  19. Confusion regarding What Counts as a Rite, and the Door of Renewalp. 61
  20. The Depth of Jurisprudential Researchp. 63
  21. Identifying the Rites between Innovation (Bidʿa) and Developmentp. 65
  22. 1 │ Deriving the Underlying Criteriap. 68
  23. 2 │ The Customary Criterionp. 71
  24. 3 │ Investigating the Exceptionsp. 74
  25. 4 │ Studying the Prohibitive Concerns and Impedimentsp. 75
  26. The Basic Manifestations of the Husayni Ritesp. 81
  27. First: Placep. 81
  28. Second: Timep. 84
  29. Third: Practicesp. 85
  30. The Ruling on the Rites and the Significations of Venerationp. 87
  31. The Collective (Kifaʾi) Obligation of the Ritesp. 90
  32. The Wilaʾi Ruling on the Ritesp. 93
  33. Clarifying the Discussions on the Wilaʾi Rulingp. 94
  34. The Sequence of Argumentation by the Wilaʾi Ruling, and the Discussion of Itp. 95
  35. In Sump. 102
  36. 4Chapter Two: Weeping and the Renewal of Griefp. 107
  37. The Rite of Weepingp. 107
  38. On the Linguistic Meaning of Weepingp. 108
  39. The Legitimacy of Weeping for Imam al-Husaynp. 109
  40. On the Theological Debate about Weepingp. 113
  41. The Content of the Objectionsp. 114
  42. Responses to the Objectionsp. 116
  43. Weeping among the Sunnisp. 120
  44. The Prophet's Weeping for al-Husaynp. 123
  45. Collective Weeping and Holding Gatherings of Mourningp. 125
  46. The Practice of the Ahl al-Bayt in Weeping for al-Husaynp. 130
  47. Making Others Weep for al-Husaynp. 135
  48. What Indicates the Renewal of Grief on the Day of ʿAshurap. 136
  49. Holding Majlises and Spreading Grief on the Day of ʿAshurap. 137
  50. What Indicates the Renewal of Grief upon the Arrival of the Month of Muharramp. 138
  51. Renewing Grief in Gatherings Generally and at All Timesp. 139
  52. Weeping for Imam al-Husayn in Prayerp. 142
  53. 5Chapter Three: Jazaʿ (Anguished Grief)p. 149
  54. Jazaʿp. 149
  55. What Is Jazaʿ?p. 150
  56. The Ruling on Jazaʿ in Generalp. 151
  57. Jurisprudential Deliberationsp. 153
  58. Summaryp. 157
  59. The Ruling on Jazaʿ for Imam al-Husaynp. 159
  60. The Importance of Jazaʿ for Imam al-Husaynp. 162
  61. The Levels of Jazaʿp. 163
  62. The Husayni Cryp. 167
  63. Tatbir: An Applied Examplep. 168
  64. Chest-Beating Processionsp. 170
  65. Is a Customary State a Condition of Jazaʿ?p. 171
  66. 6Chapter Four: Tatbir and the Ruling on Drawing Bloodp. 177
  67. Tatbir and the Ruling on Drawing Bloodp. 177
  68. Tatbir and the Difference of Jurisprudential Opinionsp. 178
  69. Tatbir between Jazaʿ and Muwasatp. 178
  70. The Proofs of Permissibility and Recommendationp. 183
  71. First: The Principle of Permissibilityp. 183
  72. Second: The Proofs of Jazaʿp. 185
  73. Third: The Explicit Proofs regarding the Act of Drawing Bloodp. 187
  74. The Fourth Proof: The Narrations on Muwasatp. 191
  75. The Fifth Proof: The Generality of Weeping and Causing Others to Weepp. 194
  76. The Proofs of Prohibitionp. 197
  77. Tatbir and Harmp. 199
  78. Which Governs: The Rule of the Rites or the Rule of Harm?p. 200
  79. The Wilaʾi Ruling of Prohibitionp. 205
  80. The Divergence of Assessmentsp. 206
  81. 7Chapter Five: Wearing Black, Raising Banners, and Public Displaysp. 213
  82. The Proofs of the Recommendation of Wearing Blackp. 214
  83. First: The Narrational Proofp. 214
  84. Second: Established Practice (Sira)p. 216
  85. Third: The Proof of the Ritesp. 221
  86. On the Dislike of Wearing Blackp. 222
  87. The First Group: Of the General Narrationsp. 223
  88. The Second Group: Of the Narrations That Prohibited Wearing Black in Prayerp. 224
  89. The Third Group: Of the Narrations That Indicate Permissibilityp. 224
  90. The Jurists' Deliberations on the Signification of the Narrationsp. 228
  91. The Strength of the Chain of the Proof of Dislikep. 230
  92. The Exception of Wearing Black in Mourning Gatheringsp. 232
  93. Corroborations for the Recommendation of Wearing Blackp. 243
  94. The Recommendation of Wearing Black Is the Well-Known View of the Juristsp. 244
  95. Public Displays in ʿAshurap. 247
  96. Examples from the Narrationsp. 249
  97. The Displays of ʿAshura Are among the Husayni Ritesp. 252
  98. 8Chapter Six: Singing and Instruments of Amusement in the Husayni Ritesp. 257
  99. First: Between Singing and Elegiesp. 259
  100. The Definition of Singing (Ghinaʾ)p. 259
  101. The Ruling on Singingp. 260
  102. Husayni Elegiesp. 261
  103. The Views of Contemporariesp. 265
  104. Second: Using Instruments of Amusement in Husayni Elegiesp. 267
  105. Instruments of Amusementp. 267
  106. The Ruling on Instruments of Amusementp. 268
  107. Instruments of Amusement in the Husayni Ritesp. 269
  108. 9Chapter Seven: Acting and Reenactmentp. 279
  109. The Objectives of Actingp. 279
  110. The Reality of the ʿAshura Reenactmentsp. 282
  111. Defining the Point of Contentionp. 283
  112. The First Aspect: Imitating Women in Actingp. 284
  113. The Rejecting Viewp. 285
  114. The Second Aspect: Representing the Event of Karbala and Portraying Its Figuresp. 291
  115. The Proofs of Permissibilityp. 291
  116. The Legal Criteriap. 295
  117. Showing the Face of the Infalliblep. 299
  118. A Contemporary View of Prohibitionp. 301
  119. 10Chapter Eight: The Jurisprudence of Lisan al-Hal (the Voice of the Situation)p. 305
  120. Prefacep. 305
  121. The Definition of Lisan al-Halp. 305
  122. Lisan al-Hal in the Husayni Ritesp. 308
  123. Those Who Reject Lisan al-Halp. 308
  124. The Proofs for Accepting Lisan al-Halp. 313
  125. Qurʾanic Argumentationp. 313
  126. Argumentation from the Sunnap. 318
  127. The Necessity of Artistic Depictionp. 322
  128. Types of Lisan al-Halp. 323
  129. Legal Criteria and Prohibitive Concernsp. 324
  130. Summary of the Criteriap. 329
  131. 11Chapter Nine: Endowment (Waqf) in the Husayni Ritesp. 333
  132. A General Introduction to Waqfp. 333
  133. What Does Waqf Mean?p. 334
  134. The Conditions of Waqfp. 336
  135. The Conditions of the Endowerp. 336
  136. The Conditions of the Endowed Propertyp. 336
  137. The Scope of Husayni Endowmentsp. 338
  138. What Are Husayniyyas?p. 338
  139. Endowing Husayniyyasp. 340
  140. The Endower and the Trusteep. 341
  141. Establishing Endowed Statusp. 342
  142. If One Endows for the Master of Martyrsp. 343
  143. Endowment and Donorsp. 348
  144. Summaryp. 352
  145. In Conclusionp. 353
  146. 12Chapter Ten: ʿAshura and the Jurisprudence of Providing Foodp. 357
  147. The Scope of Providing Food in Islamp. 357
  148. Providing Food out of Love for the Ahl al-Baytp. 359
  149. Husayni Food Provisionp. 360
  150. Between Giving to the Poor and Providing Food for Mourningp. 362
  151. Are There Conditions for Providing Food?p. 365
  152. Is There Extravagance in Husayni Food Provision?p. 366
  153. 13Chapter Eleven: The Rite of the Husayni Ziyarah and the Jurisprudence of the Arbaʿin Walkersp. 373
  154. The Concept of the Husayni Ziyarah and Its Rewardp. 373
  155. The Concept of Ziyarahp. 373
  156. Ziyarah as a Religious Termp. 375
  157. 1 │ Setting Out on the Journey, or Coming to the Noble Gravep. 376
  158. 2 │ Reciting the Text of the Ziyarah, Comprising Salutation, Supplication, and Seeking Intercessionp. 377
  159. 3 │ Prayer, a Gift for the One Visitedp. 378
  160. The Merit of the Husayni Ziyarahp. 378
  161. The Arbaʿin Ziyarah and Walking to Itp. 381
  162. The Ruling on Walking in Acts of Worshipp. 383
  163. Walking to the Ziyarah of Imam al-Husaynp. 386
  164. The Indications of Walkingp. 389
  165. Walking in the Arbaʿin Ziyarah and Its Dimensionsp. 391
  166. The Dimensions of the Link between Walking and the Arbaʿin Ziyarahp. 393
  167. The Arbaʿin Ziyarah in Jurisprudential Discussionp. 398
  168. On the Reliability of the Narrations on the Arbaʿin Ziyarahp. 399
  169. 14Chapter Twelve: On the Jurisprudence of Women in the Husayni Ritesp. 407
  170. Women and ʿAshurap. 407
  171. Are the Husayni Rites Exclusive to Men?p. 408
  172. Women in the Texts on the Ritesp. 410
  173. The Weeping of Umm al-Baninp. 413
  174. The Jurists' Views on Women's Participation in the Husayni Ritesp. 413
  175. Women Going Out into the Streets for Mourningp. 414
  176. Women, Chest-Beating and Jazaʿ for the Master of Martyrsp. 415
  177. A Menstruating Woman's Entering Places of Mourningp. 416
  178. Women Walking to Karbalap. 417
  179. Women's Voices Being Heard in Mourningp. 418
  180. Looking at Men's Processionsp. 420
  181. 15Sources and Referencesp. 423